Ice Cream 2 Scoops in a Cone on the Beach

Best Ice Cream on Tybee Island

You scream I scream we all scream for ice cream! Everyone is looking for an easy way to beat the summer heat here on Tybee Island and we have just the solution for you… Nothing gives you reprieve from the scorching summer heat like a nice cold treat. Ice cream on Tybee Island is serious business and we here at Oceanfront Cottage Rentals have been taste-testing the best shops for years. Each place is a little different but here are a few of our favorites to give a try:

  • Beau & Arrow Frozen Yogurt – This Frozen Yogurt establishment has delicious yogurt and a big selection of flavors & toppings! Enjoy an amazing selection of sugar-free options as well! Their flavors range from what you would typically expect (vanilla, chocolate, etc.) to fabulous flavors such as Georgia Peach, Mango, Pomegranate Raspberry, Cookie’s-&-Creme, and Cheesecake. Delightful drinks more your thing? They also serve wonderful coffee and amazing caramel macchiatos.


  • The Cafe on 80 – This great Cafe not only has wonderful sandwiches but it has amazing ice cream too. They boast over twenty unique flavors such as Coconut Castaway & Campfire S’more, and they serve all their ice cream by the scoop in a cup, cake cone, or waffle cone. Dress up your cone with nearly any topping you desire or turn your ice cream of choice into a scrumptious milkshake or root beer float. Cafe on 80 offers lots of yummy ways to cool down!


  • The Sugar Shack – This shop is an American staple and has been a family-owned fixture of Tybee Island since 1971. With over 45 years of business selling ice cream it has grown but still has its roots as a unique Tybee tradition, serving soft-serve ice cream, milkshakes, malts, floats, and their hometown favorite, an upside-down banana split. If you’re looking for a quick meal before you indulge in dessert, the Sugar Shack has great hamburgers, and chicken tenders, along with other sandwiches to fit the bill Experience an amazing summer tradition at this nostalgic ice cream shop & eatery!Ice Cream 2 Scoops in a Cone on the Beach

These are only a few of our favorite choices to cool down and beat the summer heat with tasty ice cream on Tybee Island. If you’re looking for more options we suggest taking a look at our Where To Eat section. There is something here for everyone and don’t forget to browse our Beachfront or Pool property vacation rentals to stay cool on your summer vacation to Tybee Island, Georgia!